New Flavors, Same Island Vibes
Castaway’s Sports Bar & Grill
Rolls Out a Mouthwatering New Menu
Singer Island’s go-to spot for food, drinks, and fun just got even better. Castaway’s Sports Bar & Grill, the locally loved, family-run favorite nestled steps from the beach, has done it again—introducing an all-new menu lineup that’s bold, crave-worthy, and full of that signature Castaway’s flair.
From juicy burgers and hearty sandwiches to flavor-packed bowls and fresh seafood creations, the new items are already making waves. Whether you’re a loyal regular or just discovering the magic of Castaway’s for the first time, this new menu rollout is a delicious reason to pull up a chair and stay awhile.
Let’s dive fork-first into the exciting additions and explore why Castaway’s new menu isn’t just a change—it’s a culinary celebration.
An Elevated Twist on Bar Food Favorites
Castaway’s has always been known for its generous portions, killer flavor combos, and casual beach-town charm—but the new dishes take things up a notch. Thoughtfully crafted by a kitchen team that knows its crowd and isn’t afraid to get creative, the new offerings blend comfort food classics with elevated twists and global inspiration.
And the best part? These aren’t just trend-chasing menu items—they’re made with fresh ingredients, bold flavors, and real passion. This is food that’s designed to satisfy your hunger and your soul.
RICOTTA DI PEPPERONI – $18
An artisan-style flatbread that will steal the show.
Pizza lovers, rejoice. The Ricotta di Pepperoni isn’t your average bar pizza—it’s a flavor-loaded, oven-baked masterpiece. Built on a rich, creamy ricotta base and layered with melty mozzarella, crispy pepperoni, and diced tomato, it’s finished with a sprinkling of grated parmesan and fresh basil that adds just the right pop of brightness.
Each bite is crispy, creamy, cheesy, and a little bit spicy, giving you all the satisfaction of a classic pepperoni pie—but with a gourmet twist. It’s perfect for sharing (or not), and pairs beautifully with a cold draft beer or one of Castaway’s handcrafted cocktails.
FIESTA BOWL – $17
All the bold flavors of a Mexican street market, in one vibrant bowl.
Looking for something hearty, healthy, and packed with flavor? Meet the Fiesta Bowl, your new go-to. This dish layers yellow rice, black beans, fresh tomato, cilantro, red onions, sweet corn, and shredded Mexican cheese into a colorful, satisfying bowl, all topped off with a drizzle of chipotle sour cream that brings the perfect smoky kick.
It’s vegetarian-friendly, but far from boring—thanks to the vibrant ingredients and well-balanced seasoning. Whether you’re fueling up after a beach day or grabbing a quick lunch between work calls, the Fiesta Bowl delivers freshness in every bite.
Pro tip: Add grilled chicken or shrimp for a protein-packed power meal.
PEEL & EAT SHRIMP – $19
A classic done right. No frills, just flavor.
Nothing says beach bar like a pile of fresh shrimp, and Castaway’s delivers with this no-nonsense, all-flavor favorite. A full pound of large white shrimp, seasoned with Old Bay and butter, arrives steaming hot and ready to peel, served with zesty cocktail sauce on the side.
These shrimp are plump, juicy, and perfectly seasoned, making them ideal for sharing with a cold beer and a side of sunshine. It’s a finger-lickin’, ocean-loving experience that reminds you why Castaway’s is the best place to unwind on Singer Island.
SHRIMP BURGER – $19
A coastal classic, reimagined.
This one’s already turning heads. The Shrimp Burger takes house-made patties of chopped shrimp—lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection—and stacks them with avocado, fresh leaf lettuce, tomato, and Old Bay mayo on a soft, buttery brioche bun.
The texture is tender but toothsome, the flavor is pure seaside goodness, and the whole thing feels indulgent without being heavy. Served with your choice of fries or tots, this is surf-style comfort food at its finest.
CARTEL BURRITO – $19
Big flavor, bold personality.
The Cartel Burrito doesn’t mess around. Packed with slow-cooked pulled pork, yellow rice, beans, corn, and Mexican cheese, all wrapped in a warm flour tortilla, this burrito is as satisfying as it is flavorful.
Each bite brings together smoky pork, sweet corn, savory rice, and melty cheese, making it the kind of dish that makes you say “wow” after the first bite. It’s messy in the best way possible—just how a burrito should be—and guaranteed to keep you full and happy long after your plate is clean.
ISLAND SANDWICH – $19
Smoky, cheesy, melty, and oh-so-satisfying.
Looking for a sandwich with a little attitude? The Island Sandwich brings all the elements of a perfect pub-style handheld—grilled chicken, sharp cheddar cheese, hickory-smoked bacon, honey mustard, and fresh veggies—all on a warm, slightly sweet pretzel bun.
The honey mustard adds just enough zing to cut through the richness, while the pretzel bun adds a chewy bite that’s wildly satisfying. It’s comfort food that doesn’t hold back—and it’s one of the most popular new menu items for good reason.
SIRLOIN SANDWICH – $20
Steak lovers, this one’s for you.
Sink your teeth into the Sirloin Sandwich, and you’ll quickly understand why it’s a new fan favorite. Thin-sliced, tender sirloin steak is piled high with provolone cheese, caramelized onions, and arugula, then topped with a cool and creamy horseradish sauce for that extra kick.
Served on a toasted brioche bun, it’s elegant enough to impress your date and hearty enough to satisfy your biggest cravings. The horseradish cream pulls it all together with a flavorful punch you won’t forget.
MAHI TACOS – $19
Fresh, vibrant, and full of island flavor.
Taco Tuesday just found its new MVP. The Mahi Tacos come two per order and are loaded with grilled mahi-mahi, mango coleslaw, and pickled red onions, all topped with a drizzle of spicy sriracha aioli.
On the side, you’ll find pico de gallo and sour cream, perfect for building the bite just how you like it. The balance of sweet, tangy, and spicy flavors will make your taste buds dance—and keep you coming back for more.
RIB & WING COMBO – $24
Two classics, one plate. No compromises.
Sometimes, you just want it all—and with the Rib & Wing Combo, you can have it. This plate gives you a half rack of slow-cooked ribs, slathered in Castaway’s house-made BBQ sauce, alongside four jumbo wings in your favorite flavor.
Choose fries or tots as your side, and you’ve got yourself the ultimate barbecue-meets-bar-food mashup. It’s messy, meaty, and ridiculously delicious.
CASTAWAY’S FULL RACK – $25
A barbecue dream come true.
If a half rack won’t cut it, go all in with Castaway’s Full Rack of Ribs. These pork ribs are fall-off-the-bone tender, smoked and sauced to perfection, and served with mashed potatoes and creamed spinach to round out a true Southern-style feast.
Need a lighter plate? A half rack is available for $20—but trust us, you’re going to want the full order.
CHIMICHURRI STEAK – $24
Simple. Elegant. Packed with flavor.
The Chimichurri Steak brings a bit of South American flair to the Castaway’s table. An 8-ounce flank steak, grilled to your liking, is drizzled with vibrant, herbaceous chimichurri sauce and served with creamy mashed potatoes and creamed spinach.
The flavor is bright and bold, the presentation is beautiful, and it’s a dish that balances indulgence with freshness—perfect for when you want something that feels a little extra special.
A Message from the Castaway’s Team
“We’re always listening to our customers and pushing ourselves to grow. These new menu items were created with our guests in mind—people who love bold flavors, high-quality ingredients, and a little fun with every meal.”
This latest menu drop is part of Castaway’s ongoing mission to deliver the best possible experience, from the food and drinks to the music and atmosphere. Whether you’re a loyal regular or a first-time visitor, there’s never been a better time to swing by, grab a seat, and taste what’s new.
So, What Are You Waiting For? Come Taste the Magic.
The new menu items are available now, and they’re already becoming staples in the Castaway’s rotation. With live music, a full bar, a killer kitchen crew, and the best vibes on the island, there’s no better place to grab a bite.
Come with friends, bring the family, or show up solo and grab a seat at the bar. However you roll, Castaway’s Sports Bar & Grill will make you feel right at home.
“Come check out our new items, the flavor will blow your tastebuds off! Come enjoy the food, have a sip of your favorite drink, and bask in the good vibes that you can only find at Castaway’s.”
